20 Things to Do on Kelleys Island, Ohio (OH)

Kelleys Island, Ohio, is a hidden gem that offers a perfect blend of natural beauty, rich history, and outdoor adventures. As the largest American island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island has long been a favorite destination for vacationers looking to escape the hustle and bustle of daily life.

Whether you're interested in exploring unique geological wonders, relaxing by the lake, or immersing yourself in the island's fascinating history, Kelleys Island is a must-visit spot for anyone seeking a tranquil retreat with things to do in Sugarcreek, Ohio (OH).

In this blog, we'll explore the top things to do on Kelleys Island, from visiting geological landmarks to enjoying outdoor activities that make this place truly special.

Unique Facts About Kelleys Island

Kelleys Island has a history and charm that set it apart from many other islands in the United States. Here's why it stands out:

• Largest American Lake Erie Island: Kelleys Island is the largest island in Lake Erie, measuring about 3.5 square miles in size. It offers plenty of space for exploration, with natural beauty and historic sites around every corner.

• Rich History Dating Back to the 19th Century: The island has a rich history, dating back to the 19th century when it was first settled. It has served as a hub for agriculture, fishing, and later, tourism.

• Geological Wonders: One of Kelleys Island’s most intriguing features is its geological formations, including the famous Glacial Grooves. These grooves are remnants of the last ice age, making them a unique attraction for visitors from all over the world.

20 Things to Do on Kelleys Island, Ohio (OH)

Kelleys Island, nestled in Lake Erie, offers an array of outdoor activities and attractions perfect for nature lovers, history enthusiasts, and anyone looking to enjoy a peaceful getaway. Whether you're hiking through its serene landscapes or exploring its rich history, Kelleys Island offers an unforgettable experience. If you're also interested in exploring rural charm, don't miss out on the many things to do in Millersburg, Ohio (OH), where you'll find a unique blend of culture and natural beauty. Here's a look at the top things to do on this beautiful island.

1. Explore the Glacial Grooves Geological Preserve

Short Description:
The Glacial Grooves Geological Preserve is one of Kelleys Island's most famous landmarks. These massive grooves, carved by ancient glaciers, are a testament to the island's geological history. It’s an awe-inspiring sight for visitors interested in geology and natural history.

Pros:

• Fascinating historical and geological significance.

• Easily accessible with a short walk to the site.

• Excellent photo opportunities.

Cons:

• Can be crowded during peak tourist seasons.

• Limited amenities on-site for longer visits.

Key Attractions and Events:

• The grooves themselves, which are among the largest in the world.

• Interpretive signs explaining the formation and history of the grooves.

2. Visit Kelleys Island State Park

Short Description:
Kelleys Island State Park is a lush 677-acre park that offers something for everyone, including picnic areas, hiking trails, and scenic views of Lake Erie. If you're exploring things to do in Newark, Ohio (OH), this park is a perfect destination for a relaxing day surrounded by nature.

Pros:

• Gorgeous waterfront views.

• Various recreational activities, including hiking and fishing.

• Campgrounds available for overnight stays.

Cons:

• The park can become quite busy during peak seasons.

• Limited dining options within the park.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Beautiful hiking trails with lake views.

• Picnic areas and the chance to enjoy a relaxing day by the water.

3. Tour the Kelleys Island Historical Museum

Short Description:
The Kelleys Island Historical Museum offers visitors a deep dive into the island's past, showcasing artifacts, photos, and exhibits related to its history. It's a great way to learn about the early settlers, the island's geology, and its role in American history.

Pros:

• Informative and educational experience.

• Offers a unique perspective on the island’s history.

• Great for history buffs and families.

Cons:

• Smaller in size, so a short visit may be all that's required.

• May not appeal to those uninterested in history.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Exhibits on the island's settlement and geological features.

• Special events and educational programs throughout the year.

4. Admire Art at Charles Herndon Sculpture Garden and Galleries

Short Description:
This unique sculpture garden and gallery is a hidden gem on Kelleys Island. It features beautiful outdoor sculptures and works of art from renowned artist Charles Herndon. It’s a perfect spot for art lovers and those looking to enjoy a tranquil outdoor space.

Pros:

• Beautiful setting surrounded by nature.

• Free to visit and explore.

• Ideal for art enthusiasts.

Cons:

• The gallery can be small, limiting the number of pieces on display.

• Limited availability of guided tours.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Outdoor sculptures set in a lush garden.

• The opportunity to purchase original artworks from local artists.

5. Hike the North Shore Alvar State Nature Preserve

Short Description:
The North Shore Alvar State Nature Preserve is a beautiful natural area offering a scenic hiking experience along the island's north shore. With its unique alvar ecosystem, it’s a great spot to see diverse plant and animal life.

Pros:

• Beautiful and diverse natural landscapes.

• A peaceful escape for nature lovers.

• Great for birdwatching and photography.

Cons:

• Trails can be challenging, especially for beginners.

• Limited amenities along the trails.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Unique alvar ecosystem and rare plant species.

• Great views of Lake Erie from the trails.

6. Kayak Around the Island

Short Description:
Exploring Kelleys Island by kayak is an exhilarating way to see the island from the water. Paddle around its shores and take in stunning views of the island’s natural beauty, including secluded beaches and dramatic rock formations.

Pros:

• Enjoy stunning views of the island and Lake Erie.

• Perfect for adventure seekers and outdoor enthusiasts.

• Ideal for all skill levels.

Cons:

• Weather conditions can affect water activity.

• Rental availability may be limited during peak seasons.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Kayaking tours offered by local providers.

• Beautiful beaches and rocky shorelines to explore.

7. Relax at the Public Beach

Short Description:
Kelleys Island offers a public beach where visitors can relax and enjoy the serene environment. The beach is perfect for sunbathing, swimming, or simply lounging by the water, making it a popular spot for families.

Pros:

• Relaxing environment with scenic views.

• Family-friendly with easy access to the water.

• Perfect for a laid-back day.

Cons:

• Can get crowded during summer weekends.

• Limited facilities and shade on the beach.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Calm waters ideal for swimming.

• Picnicking areas nearby.

8. Visit Inscription Rock

Short Description:
Inscription Rock is an important historical site on Kelleys Island, featuring ancient Native American petroglyphs. It's a fascinating spot for anyone interested in the island's early human history.

Pros:

• Rich in cultural and historical significance.

• Offers a glimpse into early Native American life.

Cons:

• The rock is difficult to access and may require a hike.

• Can be difficult to decipher the petroglyphs without a guide.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Ancient petroglyphs carved into the rock.

• Historical interpretation signage available.

9. Enjoy Wine Tasting at Kelleys Island Wine Co.

Short Description:
The Kelleys Island Wine Co. offers a delightful wine-tasting experience with locally produced wines. Enjoy scenic views of Lake Erie as you sip on a variety of wines in a relaxed setting.

Pros:

• Stunning lakefront views while enjoying wine.

• Tasting rooms with knowledgeable staff.

• Great variety of locally produced wines.

Cons:

• Wine tasting can get crowded during peak seasons.

• Limited food options available.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Wine tasting events and private tours.

• Local wine production with a focus on quality and unique flavors.

10. Play Miniature Golf at Caddy Shack Square

Short Description:
Caddy Shack Square offers a fun and family-friendly miniature golf experience. It’s a perfect activity for families or groups of friends looking to enjoy some light-hearted competition while having fun.

Pros:

• Ideal for families and casual fun.

• Affordable and easy to access.

• Lighthearted competition for all ages.

Cons:

• Limited to a single course.

• Can be crowded during peak tourist seasons.

Key Attractions and Events:

• Themed miniature golf course.

• Fun and relaxed atmosphere for families and groups.

11. Bird Watching at Scheele Preserve

Short Description: Scheele Preserve is an expansive nature reserve on Kelleys Island that offers bird watchers an incredible opportunity to see various species, especially migratory birds.

Pros:

• Peaceful environment for bird watching

• Scenic views of Lake Erie and surrounding nature

• Educational experience for all ages

Cons:

• Limited amenities on-site

• Best visited during migratory seasons for the full experience

Key Attractions and Events:

• Species of birds, including waterfowl, shorebirds, and songbirds

• Hiking trails through untouched natural beauty

---

12. Explore Abandoned Quarry Sites

Short Description: Kelleys Island was once home to limestone quarries. Today, several abandoned quarry sites are available for exploration, giving visitors a peek into the island's industrial past.

Pros:

• Fascinating historical sites

• Great for photography enthusiasts

• Off-the-beaten-path adventure

Cons:

• Some areas are inaccessible without proper footwear or guidance

• Sites may be difficult to locate without a map

Key Attractions and Events:

• The Kelleys Island Quarry Site

• The Crystal Cave, once a famous limestone mine

---

13. Bike Around the Island

Short Description: Rent a bike and explore the island's winding roads and scenic paths. Cycling is a popular way to experience Kelleys Island at a relaxed pace.

Pros:

• Eco-friendly way to travel

• Allows access to remote areas of the island

• Fun for all skill levels

Cons:

• May be difficult on steep terrains or for those unaccustomed to cycling

• Limited bike rental shops

Key Attractions and Events:

• Scenic views of Lake Erie

• Quiet, rural roads perfect for cycling

---

14. Attend Local Festivals and Events

Short Description: Kelleys Island is known for its charming festivals and events that celebrate the local culture, arts, and traditions. The island hosts events throughout the year.

Pros:

• Great for immersing in the local culture

• Fun for families and groups

• A variety of events from arts to food

Cons:

• Events may be seasonal or weather-dependent

• Popular events can get crowded

Key Attractions and Events:

• Kelleys Island Wine Festival

• Summer concert series at the town square

• Annual 4th of July fireworks

---

15. Fish in Lake Erie

Short Description: Lake Erie is known for its excellent fishing opportunities. Visitors can enjoy fishing from shore or take a guided fishing trip on the lake.

Pros:

• Abundant fish species, including perch, walleye, and bass

• Beautiful views while fishing

• Great for anglers of all levels

Cons:

• Requires a fishing license

• Best fishing spots can be crowded during peak season

Key Attractions and Events:

• Annual fishing tournaments

• Fishing charters available for deeper waters

---

16. Visit the Old Stone Church

Short Description: This historic church is a lovely spot to visit while on Kelleys Island. Built in the mid-1800s, the Old Stone Church offers a glimpse into the island's past.

Pros:

• Rich historical value

• Quiet and serene setting for reflection

• A well-preserved piece of Kelleys Island history

Cons:

• Limited visiting hours

• Not much else to see in the immediate area

Key Attractions and Events:

• Historical tours available during the summer

• Beautiful stone architecture

---

17. Shop in Downtown Kelleys Island

Short Description: Explore the quaint downtown area of Kelleys Island, where you’ll find unique shops, local art, and souvenirs perfect for remembering your trip.

Pros:

• A variety of local shops and galleries

• Great for picking up unique gifts

• Relaxed, small-town atmosphere

Cons:

• Limited shopping options compared to larger cities

• Can be pricey for souvenirs

Key Attractions and Events:

• Island art galleries featuring local artists

• Small boutiques selling handmade crafts

---

18. Enjoy Ice Cream at Dipper Dan's

Short Description: No visit to Kelleys Island is complete without stopping by Dipper Dan’s for some homemade ice cream. This local favorite is the perfect treat after a day of exploring.

Pros:

• Delicious, homemade ice cream with a variety of flavors

• Great for families and kids

• Relaxing place to take a break

Cons:

• Can get crowded during peak summer months

• Limited seating

Key Attractions and Events:

• Seasonal ice cream flavors

• Family-friendly atmosphere

---

19. Rent a Golf Cart for Island Exploration

Short Description: Renting a golf cart is a fun and efficient way to get around Kelleys Island. It’s an easy way to explore the island’s attractions without worrying about parking.

Pros:

• Easy to navigate around the island

• Ideal for small groups or families

• Environmentally friendly way to get around

Cons:

• Can be expensive compared to other forms of transport

• Limited availability during peak season

Key Attractions and Events:

• Explore the island’s secluded beaches

• Visit local wineries and breweries

---

20. Watch the Sunset at West Bay Inn

Short Description: Head to West Bay Inn for breathtaking views of the sunset over Lake Erie. It’s the perfect spot to unwind and watch the colors change as the day winds down.

Pros:

• Stunning views of Lake Erie

• Peaceful and romantic atmosphere

• Great for photography

Cons:

• Can get busy during peak times

• Limited seating areas

Key Attractions and Events:

• Beautiful sunset views

• Great place for evening walks and relaxation

Best Time to Visit Kelleys Island

The climate on Kelleys Island varies throughout the year, offering different experiences depending on the season.

• Summer (June – August): This is the peak season for tourists, offering warm weather ideal for outdoor activities such as hiking, biking, and water sports.

• Spring (April – May) and Fall (September – October): These seasons offer mild temperatures and fewer crowds, making it perfect for those looking for a more peaceful experience while still enjoying pleasant weather.

• Winter (November – March): While colder and quieter, winter on the island can still be enchanting, with fewer tourists and an opportunity to enjoy a more serene experience.

Table: Average Monthly Temperatures and Precipitation

Unique Gems of Kelleys Island

Kelleys Island is full of unique landmarks and attractions that give visitors a chance to connect with nature and the island’s rich history. Here are some must-see spots:

• Glacial Grooves State Memorial: This remarkable geological site features the world’s largest accessible glacial grooves. Formed during the Pleistocene Epoch, these grooves are a testament to the power of glacial movement. Visitors can explore these natural wonders and learn about the island’s geological significance.

• Inscription Rock: On this rock formation, ancient petroglyphs carved by Native Americans offer a glimpse into the island’s early history. The carvings are an important part of Kelleys Island’s cultural heritage, making it a significant site for history enthusiasts.

• North Shore Alvar State Nature Preserve: Known for its rare limestone ecosystem, this preserve is unique to Kelleys Island. It provides an opportunity for nature lovers to explore diverse flora and fauna in a tranquil environment.

Suggested Day Itinerary

To make the most of your visit to Kelleys Island, here's a suggested itinerary that will allow you to experience the best of the island:

• Morning: Start your day by visiting the Glacial Grooves State Memorial. Take time to appreciate the geological history of the island and enjoy a leisurely walk through the park.

• Midday: For lunch, head to one of the local cafes on the island and enjoy regional specialties, including fresh fish and locally grown produce.

• Afternoon: After lunch, rent a golf cart or bicycle to explore the scenic trails that wind through the island’s countryside. You’ll pass by charming cottages, peaceful beaches, and picturesque nature spots.

• Evening: Finish your day with a relaxing dinner at a waterfront restaurant. Enjoy delicious food while watching the stunning sunset over Lake Erie.

How to Reach Kelleys Island

Getting to Kelleys Island is convenient, whether you prefer to travel by water or air.

• By Ferry: Regular ferry services operate from Marblehead and Sandusky, Ohio, providing easy access for visitors. The ferry ride offers beautiful views of Lake Erie, making it an enjoyable part of your trip.

• By Air: If you prefer flying, Kelleys Island has a small public airport that accommodates private planes. This option is ideal for those looking to arrive in style and avoid the ferry.

Conclusion

Kelleys Island, Ohio, is a perfect destination for those seeking a peaceful getaway with a rich mix of natural beauty, historical landmarks, and outdoor activities. While you're exploring the island, don't miss out on the things to do in Yellow Springs, Ohio (OH), which offer an equally charming experience with its unique attractions and scenic spots. The unique attractions, serene atmosphere, and welcoming community make it a destination worth visiting year-round.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: What are the operating hours of the ferry service to Kelleys Island?

Ferry schedules vary by season. It’s recommended to check the official ferry websites for the most current information.

Q2: Are there accommodations available on Kelleys Island?

Yes, the island offers a variety of lodging options, including cozy bed and breakfasts, charming cottages, and peaceful campgrounds.

Q3: Is Kelleys Island suitable for families with children?

Absolutely! The island offers many family-friendly activities, including biking, fishing, hiking, and visiting local parks.

Q4: Are pets allowed on the island?

Pets are allowed in certain areas, including some campgrounds. However, it's advisable to check with specific accommodations and activity providers about their pet policies.